Elden Ring gave me an item that boosts my damage, and I carried it, unused, through the entire game. Not because I forgot it. Because I ran the math, every single boss fight, and the math always said no.
Here's the spiral, and it's the same one every time. I could pop the buff on this attempt — but I'm almost certainly not killing the boss on this attempt, so I'd just burn the item and feel like an idiot. Okay, save it for the attempt that matters. But which attempt matters? So I wait until my runs get good, until I'm dying with the boss at a sliver of health, and then using the item distracts me, I fumble the run I was about to win, and now I've wasted it AND lost. Fine. Ignore the item, lock in, kill the boss clean over the next few tries — and now the buff is useless because I already won without it. WHO is this item for. When is it ever meant to be used. I promptly decide I'll figure that out later, and never touch it again for the rest of the game.
I'm not a designer handing down verdicts. I'm a player taking games apart to figure out how they work, and mostly what I've learned is how good I am at robbing my own fun.
The seam
There's a game-design law I keep circling back to, from Soren Johnson: given the opportunity, players will optimize the fun out of a game. Every decent developer knows it now and builds around it. Sitting with that, my own corollary fell out almost by accident:
"any time that the best strategy is not the most fun strategy, I believe, is a failure of the game's design."— me, thinking too hard about consumables
That's the seam. The quiet place where the smart play and the good time come apart, and the game leaves you holding the knife. Once you feel it you can't stop feeling it. The Witcher 3 — one of my favorite games ever made — has this gorgeous system where you oil your blade to shred specific monsters, and I oiled a sword maybe twice in the whole game. Sekiro firecrackers I never threw. Prey's recycler charge on nightmare, where I tested one, watched it one-shot an enemy, went save it for something scary, hit something scary, used one, and it did basically nothing — so I save-scummed around the fight instead and hoarded the rest for an occasion that never came. The best strategy was always to use the thing. The most fun, for my broken optimizer brain, was to save it forever.
A perfect object closes that seam. Here are the ones that do it, and one that finally showed me how.
Silksong — the fix that's stupidly small
Silksong has shards. Ammo, basically — you collect them off dead enemies and fire off projectiles that help with the occasional obstacle or boss. Classic consumable, classic hoard: I ran out of a few during boss attempts and immediately went back to never touching them.
Then it stopped letting me stockpile. There's a cap — 400 — and one day the counter just quit going up. I went to grab more and couldn't. And that is the whole trick: the moment I couldn't hoard, I finally started using them. I'd spend a few on a flying enemy I didn't feel like fighting, watch the counter refill toward the cap, get a little braver each time. By the end I was dumping almost my whole supply on a boss and feeling completely fine about it.
It didn't fix my skill — I still had to learn to beat that boss the honest way. But it was the first game where I regularly used the fun stuff instead of guarding it like a dragon. The design doesn't lecture you out of optimizing; it quietly removes the reward for it. Helping players help themselves — or, less generously, protecting players from their own need to optimize. Souls games already do it with healing flasks that refill on every rest, which is why you spend those freely. Nobody thought to point the same idea at everything else. A cap and a promise of more, and that's the whole fix.
Balatro — no seam to begin with
Balatro is the game that made me believe a perfect object was even possible, which is why it gets its own whole page. No consumable to hoard, no boring grind — the min-maxing is the game. You build a scoring engine out of playing cards and jokers, and building it well is the entire dopamine hit. Nowhere does playing smart and playing fun pull apart.
Now the honest part, because I'd rather say it than have you notice it: that's exactly what makes it dangerous for me. The same seamlessness that makes it perfect makes it very hard to put down. I haven't so much finished understanding Balatro as stopped being able to stop. Which left me with a question I can't shake — what does that closed-seam magic do to dice instead of cards? — and that itch is a thing I've actually started trying to build, badly, the way you do when a game gets under your skin.
Outer Wilds — the progression is you
The whole game is your own understanding. Nothing about your character gets stronger; only you do. The progress bar lives in your head. So there's no grind to optimize and no fun to optimize away — a completely different way to close the same seam, math nowhere in sight. Go in knowing nothing and protect that. I genuinely can't say more without robbing you, which tells you everything about how tightly it's put together.
Into the Breach — every turn fully readable
Most strategy games hide their math behind dice and fog. Into the Breach shows you exactly what every enemy will do next turn and then asks: okay, solve it. Turns out perfect information makes a game harder and far more honest — when you lose, it's because you misread the board, not because the game rolled you. No randomness for the smart play to hide behind, no luck to blame. It's a puzzle box that respects you completely, runs on basically anything, and is the kindest hard game I know.
A few more, same lens
I sort games by what they ask of you, and a handful keep earning their spot:
- FTL — small, brutal, every run a fresh disaster you half-caused. The tension is all yours.
- Slay the Spire — the deckbuilder that taught me a run can be a story you build, then lose, then immediately want to build again.
- Inside — proof a game can say a lot while explaining nothing. Short, beautiful, no fat.
- Witcher 3 — my all-time favorite, seams and all. I love it despite the blade oil I never used, which is sort of the whole point of this page.
I'm wary of crowning any of these. I'm still learning the craft by playing, and half of what's on this page I only worked out by watching my own bad habits — the items I hoard, the smart plays I skip because they're boring. Being right about which games are "best" was never the point. Noticing that I can't put this down and I respect how this is built sometimes point at the exact same thing was — and that in most other games, the gap between them is a design problem hiding in plain sight.
Gaming was the original obsession — the one I wrote a whole novel as a cover story for, the same itch that now runs a table full of dice on the weekends. Same rabbit hole. I just keep finding new doors.
Keep going Why Balatro is a perfect game · A dice roguelike